The publishing industry’s shameful betrayal of Kate Clanchy

Pan Macmillan has publicly apologised for yielding to ideological pressure several years ago. The case of Kate Clanchy, once a celebrated author, became emblematic of the industry’s moral panic and fear-driven censorship.

The cancellation of an acclaimed writer

Four years ago, Clanchy faced a rapid and devastating backlash. Her memoir, Some Kids I Taught and What They Taught Me, published two years prior, was accused by authors and social media users of containing racist and ableist portrayals. In response, her publisher Picador promptly issued an apology and pledged to revise the book.

Publisher’s retreat and apology

Following the controversy, Clanchy and Picador ended their partnership. Now, Pan Macmillan — Picador’s parent company — has expressed formal regret for its handling of the situation.

‘I’m sorry for the hurt that was caused to Kate Clanchy,’ said CEO Joanna Prior, describing her experience as part of ‘a regrettable series of events in Pan Macmillan’s past.’

A reflection on a damaging episode

Clanchy, recipient of the Orwell Prize and a teacher with nearly thirty years of experience, became a victim of an overzealous campaign amid heightened political sensitivities following the Black Lives Matter movement. The affair, once considered a major cultural reckoning, is now broadly recognised as a troubling act of institutional cowardice.

Clanchy’s work revisited

Some Kids I Taught and What They Taught Me offered a compassionate portrayal of her teaching years and was warmly received before being condemned. The publisher’s new apology signals an attempt to acknowledge past errors and rehabilitate its reputation.

Author’s summary: The article criticises the publishing industry's capitulation in the Kate Clanchy case and notes Pan Macmillan’s belated apology as an overdue act of accountability.

Spiked — 2025-11-09